Anastasia Island - We currently have 1 Anastasia Island vacation homes, condos and villas listed on this page!

Anastasia Island, Florida

Many visitors to the state of Florida concentrate their attention on Orlando and the Everglades, never even realizing that tourism in Florida extends beyond the coastline to dozens of small islands in the Atlantic. These islands offer another experience of Florida, with vacation homes on Anastasia Island providing tourists the opportunity to visit Fort Matanzas National Monument, which contains a fort built during the era of Spanish colonization.

Classed as a barrier island, Anastasia Island is about 18 miles long and lies quite near the city of St. Augustine. Unlike some islands, Anastasia is separated from mainland Florida not by a mile or more of ocean, but by the Matanzas River. Indeed, portions of the island are so close to the mainland that they are considered inside the city limits of St. Augustine. Beaches on Anastasia Island include Butler Beach, St. Augustine Beach, and Crescent Beach.

The Fountain of Youth?

Florida has long been fabled to contain the legendary Fountain of Youth originally discovered by Spanish explorer Juan Ponce de Len. Historical sources suggest that Ponce de Len may have landed on Anastasia Island in 1513, which leaves open the possibility that the Fountain of Youth is located off the mainland.

Unusual Construction

One of the joys of a visit to Anastasia Island is the chance to see coquina building techniques up close. Coquina refers to a type of coarse shell material that can be used like stones. The Spanish and the British both built of coquina here, with the Castillo de San Marcos a notable example of the technique

Narrow Your Results
Rental Type
Pet Friendly Type
Sort results by:
  • Anastasia Island, Florida
    Oceanfront Resort on Anastasia Island with direct access to miles of beautiful sandy beach, located just 10 minutes south of St. Augustine bayfront, marina and downtown historic district with all the charm of its Spanish...
    Call Owner For Payment Details
    Bedrooms Bathrooms Rental type Pet friendly Daily Rate Weekly Rate Monthly Rate
    2 2 Resort
    $0 - $0 $450 - $700 $0 - $0

Looking for vacation rentals near to Anastasia Island ?

St. Augustine Beach Vacation Rentals By Owner  St. Augustine Vacation Rental By Owner  Palm Coast Vacation Home Rentals  Flagler Beach Vacation Homes  Ponte Vedra Beach Vacation Home Rentals  Jacksonville Beach Condo Rentals  Ormond Beach Rental Vacation Homes  Holly Hill Vacation Rentals  Daytona Beach Vacation By Owner  Daytona Beach Shores Owner Vacation Rentals  
Learn More About
Anastasia Island
Below you will find writings from other Anastasia Island vacation rental owners about the area they know best! It's a great way to learn first hand about the Anastasia Island region and all that it has to offer!

If you are a registered vacation rental property owner on and want to tell everyone about the Anastasia Island area and additional exposure for your listing, please login here and click on 'Edit Your Listing!'